130+ Halloween Would You Rather Questions

If you’ve been wondering what ‘Halloween Would You Rather’ is all about, here’s a short explanation of how to play.

Would You Rather is a question game in which you have to choose between two options (sometimes called This or That questions.)

It’s a fun question game that can also be used as an icebreaker or conversation starter at parties.

The Halloween version of Would You Rather includes many dark and scary questions. So be prepared for some seriously spooky questions. 

🎃 You might also enjoy:

• Scary Halloween Dares For Teens & Tweens
• College Halloween Costumes (Cute, Easy & Cheap!)
• Ghoulish Halloween Party Games For Tweens & Teens
• Fun Halloween Youth Group Games

Would You Rather Halloween Questions

Halloween is just around the corner, so this is the right time to check out some of the games and questions that are available to you. Some Halloween Would You Rather Questions are appropriate for kids and teenagers, and others apply to adults only.

Halloween Would You Rather Questions are divided into different categories; scary, spooky, horror, and creepy, each suitable for a specific setting and age group.

You can also download all these questions and print them out at home.

Scariest Would You Rather Questions

1. Would you rather be chased by one vampire or 10 zombies?

2. Would you rather be a wild animal or have alien features?

3. Would you rather die from freezing or burn to death?

4. Would you rather eat a fried snake or a salted scorpion?

5. Would you rather die suddenly and painlessly at 30 or miserably and slowly at 90?

6. Would you rather have hands for legs or have legs for hands?

7. Would you rather know when you will die or how you will die?

8. Would you rather have no eyes or no toes?

9. Would you rather have a dentist appointment or watch a horror series?

10. Would you rather walk like a zombie or look like one?

11. Would you rather bungee jump or skydive?

12. Would you rather go back in time or teleport to the future?

13. Would you rather sleep in a coffin overnight or hang upside down from a tree?

14. Would you rather cut off all your toes or get married into the Addams family?

15. Would you rather spend a whole week inside a haunted abandoned house with ghosts or in a graveyard at midnight?

16. Would you rather be featured in American Horror Story or in Haunting of Hill House?

17. Would you rather carry a curse to die young or live forever?

Would You Rather Teenage Questions

These questions for teens will spice up their Halloween night. 

18. Would you rather stick your hand in a box filled with worms or not know what is in the box?

19. Would you rather live with a dog that talks or a cat that walks on two feet?

20. Would you rather hear a scary cackle or bone-chilling scream?

21. Would you rather eat a raw snail or a raw snake?

22. Would you rather own a black cat or a black bat?

23. Would you rather be stung by a bee or scratched by a cat?

24. Would you rather pee all day and never poop or poop all day and never pee?

25. Would you rather go to a haunted hotel or a haunted corn maze?

26. Would you rather lick a public sidewalk or the bottom of someone’s shoes?

27. Would your rather have your hair pulled out or your nails plucked out?

28. Would you rather communicate only by whispering or talking loudly over everybody else?

29. Would you rather be kept in a zoo for people to see you or held in the wild?

30. Would you rather speak from the back of your head or the bottom of your feet?

31. Would you rather lick a stranger’s feet or the feet of someone you know?

32. Would you rather be a ghost or a zombie?

33. Would you rather have an invisible friend or have no friends at all?

34. Would you rather wake up to a zombie apocalypse or an invasion of 10-ft spiders?

Watch and play this Would You Rather? Halloween Edition game below:

Would You Rather Halloween Edition

35. Would you rather wear a homemade costume for Halloween or a store-bought one?

36. Would you rather meet with a real-life vampire or a werewolf?

37. Would you rather have vampire teeth or werewolf fur?

38. Would you rather go ghost hunting or set traps for vampires?

39. Would you rather watch horror films for the rest of your life or comedy films?

40. Would you rather see an actual vampire through your bedroom window or a wolf inside your room?

41. Would you rather be led by a headless horseman or fly with a blind pilot?

42. Would you rather be a human centipede or a scorpion?

43. Would you rather lie in a bathtub filled with a pool of blood or one filled with worms?

44. Would you rather have candy for breakfast or candy for dinner?

45. Would you rather be in a bed in a haunted neighborhood or sleep at a cemetery at midnight?

46. Would you rather be the one scaring people at Halloween or be scared at Halloween?

October Would You Rather Questions

47. Would you rather ride on a broom like a witch or be tiny like a fairy?

48. Would you rather have a one-on-one conversation with Frankenstein or talk to your own ghost?

49. Would you rather dress up as a ghost or as a witch?

50. Would you rather eat only candy corn for the rest of your life or gummies?

51. Would you rather be able to transform into a dog or a cat for one day?

52. Would you rather attend a costume party or a masquerade ball?

53. Would you rather live with a wizard or a witch?

54. Would you rather go trick or treating or carve out a pumpkin?

55. Would you rather be alone while trick or tricking or go with many friends?

56. Would you rather be trapped inside a big web or be covered in slime from head to toe?

57. Would you rather dress up as a witch on Halloween or as a mummy?

58. Would you rather sleep inside a graveyard or in a haunted house for one night?

59. Would you rather eat dark chocolate all day every day or sour candy?

60. Would you rather be the one passing out candy or go trick-or-treating?

61. Would you rather break a mirror for bad luck or see a black cat cross your path?

62. Would you rather take an evening swim in a dark lake or go for a midnight walk in a cemetery? 

Halloween Would You Rather Questions For Adults

Adult Halloween party games are just as popular as kids-themed games. 

63. Would you rather spend a whole year having nightmares or have a scary monster living under your bed for one year?

64. Would you rather have a root canal or never have coffee again?

65. Would you rather eat a ghost pepper or see a ghost?

66. Would you rather eat a bowl of flesh or drink a cup of blood?

67. Would you rather be attacked by 30 tarantulas or by 30 bats?

68. Would you rather be demon-possessed or locked in a haunted house forever?

69. Would you rather watch romantic movies for the rest of your life or watch horror movies for the rest of your life on replay?

70. Would you rather your flesh be feasted on by maggots or by piranhas?

71. Would you rather be killed by a vampire or killed by a werewolf?

72. Would you rather die in the hands of aliens or a psychopath?

73. Would you rather live as a zombie or a vampire?

Would You Rather Questions For Kids Halloween

Some of these Halloween questions can be a bit creepy, so here are some child-friendly questions that you can use instead.

74. Would you rather have a pumpkin head or skeleton fingers?

75. Would you rather eat one trick or treat every day for a year or eat all of your gummy candies and treats in one day?

76. Would you rather eat no candy at Halloween or no turkey at Thanksgiving?

77. Would you rather have a secret magic wand or a flying broomstick?

78. Would you rather have Halloween every day for the whole year or only one day?

79. Would you rather watch a scary movie or play a spooky game?

80. Would you rather play a prank on both your parents at the same time or your siblings at different times?

81. Would you rather eat two raw garlic cloves or two raw onions?

82. Would you rather have a midnight stroll at a graveyard alone or walk in the woods at night alone?

83. Would you rather dress as a superhero for Halloween or dress as a villain for Halloween?

84. Would you rather stay home and watch a horror movie with your family for Halloween or go trick or treating with your friends?

85. Would you rather have a vampire or a zombie for a friend?

86. Would you rather lay in a bathtub filled with worms or a bathtub filled with furry spiders?

87. Would you rather eat only sour gummies or bags of candy corn for the rest of your life?

88. Would you rather shapeshift into a black cat or shapeshift into a bat?

89. Would you rather burp or fart loudly every time you get scared?

90. Would you rather eat frogs’ legs or kiss a toad?

91. Would you rather have a ghost in your closet or a monster under your bed?

92. Would you rather go to school with Harry Potter or Sabrina the Teenage Witch?

93. Would you rather choose your pumpkin from a pumpkin patch or bake pumpkin pie?

94. Would you rather wear a funny Halloween costume or a scary costume?

95. Would you rather eat a homemade candy apple or a bowl of candy corn?

Horror Would You Rather Questions

96. Would you rather have a two-hour dinner date with Patrick Bateman or go out for a one-hour picnic with Hannibal Lecter?

97. Would you rather have a dream with “The Ring” girl or have real-life hallucinations with Freddy Krueger from “A Nightmare on Elm Street“?

98. Would you rather get murdered by Jigsaw from “Saw” or be murdered by Chucky?

99. Would you rather be chased for the rest of your life by the creature from “It Follows” or be pursued for the rest of your life by Pennywise?

100. Would you rather book a whole night and stay in Room 1408 or book an entire night at Bates Motel?

101. Would you rather read the book from “The Babadook” or repeat the words “Bloody Mary” in front of the mirror three times?

102. Would you rather have your whole leg eaten by the shark from “Jaws” or be stabbed by the killer from “Scream”?

103. Would you rather live in the house from “Paranormal Activity” or in the house from “Insidious”?

104. Would you rather be a character in “The Purge” or “Resident Evil”?

105. Would you rather have your eyes gorged out with a fork or scooped out using a spoon?

Spooky Would You Rather Questions

106. Would you rather anger Maleficent or the Wicked Witch of the West?

107. Would you rather be in a fight with a giant bug or a giant spider?

108. Would you rather be bitten by a werewolf or a vampire?

109. Would you rather be in a fight with Dracula or with The Mummy?

110. Would you rather be possessed by Chucky or Annabelle?

111. Would you rather have a scorpion sting you or a rattlesnake bite you?

112. Would you rather have a head the size of a ping pong ball or a large watermelon?

113. Would you rather see Chucky in real life or Pennywise?

114. Would you rather wear your shoes with sauce inside or wear your socks damp from pee?

115. Would you rather swallow a tarantula or a snake?

116. Would you rather have a neck the size of a giraffe or teeth the size of a shark?

117. Would you rather be the last one to be turned into a zombie or the first one in a zombie apocalypse?

118. Would you rather live with a talking pet dog or cat?

119. Would you rather be possessed by a demon or a ghost?

Creepy Would You Rather Questions

120. Would you rather live with a serial killer or a psychopath?

121. Would you rather die bleeding out or die being set on fire?

122. Would you rather turn into a cannibal because of starvation or die hungry?

123. Would you rather have the ghost of someone you know appear to you or the ghost of a total stranger? 

124. Would you rather be eaten by a wolf or bitten by a vampire?

125. Would you rather spend a whole night in a haunted house alone or sleep in a graveyard alone? 

126. Would you rather a psychopath break into your house or a serial killer?

127. Would you rather save your parents in a plane crash or your sibling?

128. Would you rather die from electrocution or from drowning?

129. Would you rather eat a human heart or a human eye?

130. Would you rather see a ghost or a spaceship?

131. Would you rather kill someone with a hammer or stab them with a knife?

132. Would you rather see a demon in real life or an angel?

Halloween Would You Rather PDF Printable

Download this Free Halloween Printable with over 130 Would You Rather questions and print it out at home.

Would You Rather is a fun game for kids and adults and is easy to play anywhere. You can use these questions as discussion starters in groups or play them as a silly game during game night.