Homework has been a part of the education system for a long time. It is an academic task assigned to students outside of regular class time to reinforce learning and help them develop skills such as time management, self-discipline, and independent thinking.
However, there has been an ongoing debate about whether homework is necessary or detrimental to a student’s academic and personal development.
Should students have homework? In this article, we will examine the pros and cons of homework to help you decide for yourself.
🎓 You might also be interested in reading: Is Grammarly Cheating? Can Students Use It?
The Pros And Cons Of Homework
To provide you with a summary of the benefits and drawbacks of homework, we have examined some key arguments.
Let’s start by taking a closer look at the potential benefits that assignments can provide for students.
The Benefits of Homework
As students, we have all groaned at the thought of homework, but did you know that homework can actually be beneficial? There are many reasons why homework assignments can be good for you. Let’s take a closer look at homework’s pros and why it benefits students.
1. Improved Knowledge Retention
One of the main benefits of homework is increased knowledge retention. When students review and practice what they have learned in class, it helps to solidify the information in their minds.
Homework allows a student to delve into a topic by going back and referring to what was taught in class and doing additional research by themselves, leading to a deeper understanding of a topic. This can be especially important for subjects that build upon previous knowledge, such as math or science.
There’s not always enough time for students in the school day to fully comprehend core concepts, but homework can counteract those effects, helping students in the long run, even if they can’t see it immediately.
By completing homework assignments, students can reinforce their understanding of the material and improve their overall comprehension.
2. Improved Academic Achievement
Homework has been shown to improve student achievement in terms of grades, test scores, and college acceptance rates. According to a professor at Duke University, there is a correlation between homework and academic success for older students.
A study published in the High School Journal found that students who spend between 31 and 90 minutes each day on homework “scored about 40 points higher on the SAT-Mathematics subtest than their peers, who reported spending no time on homework each day, on average.”
In a study conducted by the Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA), boys who had more homework had higher GPAs and a higher likelihood of attending college. The average high school boy who attended college did more than three hours of extra homework a week.
🎓 Suggested reading: Does Dropping A Class Affect Your GPA?
2. Establish Good Study Habits
Homework can also help to improve study habits. Students can develop a routine and establish good study habits by setting aside time each day to complete tasks. This can be especially helpful for students who struggle with time management or procrastination. By getting into the habit of completing homework assignments regularly, students can develop a sense of discipline and responsibility.
The discipline of practice and commitment that goes into doing unsupervised homework and independent learning leads to improved study skills and habits. In the long run, the ability to study and do research by yourself makes it possible for you to learn how to be more creative and find ways to apply your understanding of class work.
3. Helps Prepare For Exams
A student’s homework can also be a valuable way to prepare for exams. As a result of completing practice problems and reviewing material on their own, students can gain a better understanding of the material and be prepared for exams.
The study habits developed when doing homework come in handy when revising for exams. The skills and methods you acquire can be applied when preparing for exams. In addition to improving test scores, this can also reduce test anxiety.
4. Time Management
Furthermore, homework can teach students essential life skills such as time management, organization, and responsibility. By completing assignments independently, students can learn how to manage their time effectively and prioritize their tasks.
These skills can be applied not only in school but also in their future careers and personal lives. Proper time management skills are needed to do an assignment on time and to complete it while juggling other things like chores and extra-curricular activities.
Being able to manage time well is a key skill that students carry with them and use even after school. The ability to study by yourself requires one to be a hard worker, focused, and able to select and decipher information relevant to specific topics.
🎓You might be interested in reading15 Good Excuses To Not Go To School (With Sample Letters)
5. Provides An Opportunity For Parent Support
Homework can also be beneficial for students because it provides an opportunity for parents to be involved in their child’s education. As a result of take-home assignments, parents can keep track of what their children are learning at school and their academic strengths and weaknesses.
When parents help their children with homework, it can create a sense of collaboration and support. This can be especially important for students who struggle with certain subjects or who need extra help. By working together, parents and students can achieve academic success.
🎓 You might also enjoy reading: How To Use ChatGPT Ethically As A Learning Tool For Students
The Drawbacks Of Homework
Many students dread doing homework every night, and it’s not hard to see why. Homework has numerous disadvantages, from increased stress levels to lost free time.
1. Increased Stress And Anxiety
One of the most significant cons of homework is the impact it can have on students’ mental health. The pressure to complete assignments and perform well on tests can be overwhelming, leading to increased stress levels and anxiety. This can be especially true for students who have extra-curricular activities, family obligations, or other responsibilities outside of school.
Students who have too much homework may lose motivation and interest in their studies. When they feel overwhelmed and overworked, they may disengage from their coursework and become unable to focus during class.
The overwhelmed student starts to get frustrated and will most likely develop a negative attitude towards school or even dislike certain subjects. This kind of attitude overrides the key purpose of going to school: learning and gaining knowledge.
🎓 Suggested reading: Coping Skills For Teens With Anxiety, Depression & Anger
2. Not Enough Free Time
Another negative effect of homework is the loss of free time. When students spend hours each night completing assignments, they have less time to pursue other interests and hobbies, spend time with friends and family, or simply relax and recharge. This can lead to feelings of frustration and resentment towards schoolwork, which can ultimately impact students’ academic performance.
It should not take longer than an hour a day on homework or an hour and a half to finish, especially for young children in primary or elementary school students. Their attention span is usually 80-90 minutes, ideal for homework per day; after this, they zone off, and the strain to focus becomes too hard. Sectioning off one hour or thirty minutes of homework leaves them time to engage in physical activity and hobbies, which are equally important.
🎓 Suggested reading: How Many Days Of School Can You Miss?
3. Physical Consequences
Moreover, homework can also have physical consequences. Sitting for extended periods, staring at a screen, and holding awkward positions can lead to eye strain, headaches, and other health issues. Students who are not getting enough sleep due to excessive homework may also experience a range of physical health problems, including fatigue and weakened immune systems.
🎓 Suggested reading: 6 Reasons Why Teens Stay Up Late
4. Widens Inequality Gap
Finally, homework can widen the achievement gap between students. For those who have supportive families and access to resources, completing homework assignments may be easy and stress-free. However, for students who lack access to these resources or face challenges outside of school, homework can become an added burden that hinders their academic progress.
5. Not Always Effective
Tasks and assignments that need to be completed at home, are not effective if they are completely separate and unrelated to school work. Only learning tasks that ask students to revise taught information that they have already covered in class, then to have a positive impact.
It is therefore extremely important that teachers only assign tasks when revision is needed to avoid unnecessary stress or take time away from other, equally important activities.
🎓 Suggested reading: What Happens If You Fail A Class In High School?
The Debate Over Homework
For years, there has been a debate raging over the effectiveness of homework. Some people believe that it’s essential to student success, while others argue that it’s unnecessary and even counterproductive.
Watch these teachers and students discuss the homework debate:
Proponents of homework argue that it helps students reinforce concepts learned in class. They believe that homework is a necessary part of the learning process and that students who complete their homework assignments are more likely to succeed academically.
Homework opponents, however, argue that it puts unnecessary stress on students and can harm their mental health. Also, they argue that homework only sometimes leads to better academic performance and that it can be a waste of time for both students and teachers.
One of the main arguments for homework is that it helps students develop time management and organizational skills. By giving students homework assignments, they learn to prioritize their workload and manage their time effectively. This can be an important skill for students to develop, especially as they move on to higher education and the workforce.
Another argument for homework is that these assignments can provide valuable feedback to both students and teachers about what concepts need further clarification or practice.
However, opponents of homework argue that it can have negative effects on students’ mental health. A study conducted by the Stanford Graduate School of Education found that excessive homework can lead to sleep deprivation, physical exhaustion, and increased stress levels. This can have serious implications for students, both in terms of their academic performance and overall well-being.
Moreover, some argue that homework can be a waste of time for both students and teachers. Teachers spend a significant amount of time grading homework assignments, which takes away from the time they could be spending developing lesson plans or working with students one-on-one. For students, homework can be a tedious and time-consuming task that might do more harm than good.
So, what’s the verdict? Is homework essential to student success, or is it an outdated and counterproductive practice?
For some students, homework may be a necessary part of their learning process. They may thrive on the structure and routine of completing homework assignments, and it may help them develop important skills like time management and organization.
Even though there are some disadvantages of homework and it is seen as a burden, sometimes it helps develop a personal work ethic in addition to knowledge development. Involvement in homework can and is meant to teach a student the aspect of determination and working on stuff even when you don’t want to.
After-school work assignments also teach responsibility and develop problem-solving skills and critical thinking because a student is expected to work on something unsupervised, which is an important life skill. Doing homework helps students get more organized with their coursework, participate, and apply themselves more in class.
However, it seems that there is a limit to homework effectiveness. A study by Denise Pope and her colleagues found that too much homework can be counterproductive and diminish its effectiveness. Based on prior research, they suggest that high school students should not spend more than 90 minutes to two and a half hours on homework each night.
The generally agreed rule of homework is that students should spend no more than 10 minutes a night per grade level – from 10 minutes in first grade to two hours of homework in high school.
The Role of Parents and Teachers in Homework
Homework is an essential part of a student’s academic life, and it has been proven to be a valuable tool in enhancing learning and academic success. It allows students to reinforce what they have learned in the classroom and to develop critical thinking skills. However, the role of parents and teachers in homework is crucial for its success.
So how can parents and teachers play a significant role in helping students achieve their academic goals?
Parents play a critical role in their child’s education, and positive involvement in their child’s homework is vital. Research has shown that parental involvement in homework positively affects academic achievement. When parents take an active interest in their child’s homework, it shows the child that education is essential, and it sets a positive tone for learning.
However, parents should resist the urge to do assignments on behalf of their children. One way parents can help students is by creating a schedule that accommodates after-school activities and allows time to work on projects.
Parents can also help their children with homework by creating a designated study area, setting a regular homework schedule, and providing necessary materials such as pencils, paper, and calculators. They can also review their child’s completed homework and offer constructive feedback and praise.
🎓 Suggested reading: Things You Should Stop Doing For Your Teenager
Teachers also play a crucial role in their student’s academic success. Homework is an excellent way for teachers to assess students’ understanding of the material and identify areas where students may need additional help. A teacher should gauge students’ understanding of a topic before giving homework.
They are responsible for assigning homework that is relevant to the material covered in class and challenging enough to help students develop critical thinking skills. Teachers can support students by providing quality homework assignments, giving clear and concise instructions for homework assignments, giving feedback and grading promptly, and answering questions or offering additional support as needed.
However, teachers must also be mindful of the amount of homework they assign. Studies have shown that excessive homework can have negative effects on students, such as an increased source of stress, decreased motivation, and decreased academic achievement. Therefore, teachers must strike a balance between homework that is challenging but not overwhelming.
Teachers should also keep in mind that students are given homework for each class and be mindful that they don’t overburden them with assignment deadlines that overlap with other subjects.
It is also important for teachers and parents to collaborate to support students with their homework. Communication between parents and teachers can help identify any difficulties a student is experiencing with homework and develop strategies to overcome them.
It is also important for parents to inform teachers if their child has any challenges at home, such as illness or family problems, that might interfere with their ability to complete their homework.
Conclusion
There are both benefits and drawbacks to homework, and its usefulness in the educational system is still debated. Despite the positive effects of homework on a student’s mental health, too much homework can potentially harm a student’s mental health. Therefore, educators must strike a balance between assigning homework and allowing students time after school for other important activities.
Teachers can support students by providing clear instructions, grading promptly, and striking a balance between challenging but not overwhelming homework assignments.
Parents can help their children with homework by providing support, creating a designated study area, and reviewing completed homework.
Collaboration between parents and teachers is also essential in supporting students’ homework and addressing any challenges they may face. By working together, parents and teachers can help students achieve their academic goals and develop the skills necessary for future success.
